What does a theater geek do when she’s run out of local shows to review (or time to see said shows)? Well, she digs up old shows, remembering how great each one of them is, and writes about them instead. Now I’m going to give you my suggested Ultimate Showtunes Playlist, or at least, as close to “ultimate” as I can get in 20 songs. (A lot of the best showtunes ever were left off this list, purely for the sake of keeping the length sane.) I’ve compiled this list trying to draw from all the styles and stories that have been on Broadway in the last fifty years or so, and included many of my personal favorites. (Plus I’ve included some samples of each song for you – 30 second clips that I think showcase the music much better than iTunes or Amazon previews.)
So, let’s get right to it, shall we? Here is my Ultimate Showtunes Playlist, listed in order of release.
1. “You Can’t Get a Man With a Gun” from Annie Get Your Gun (1946) – this song is a favorite of mine because it turns the classic heartbreak moment in a romance story into a comedy song. As the at least partially true story goes, Annie Oakley, female sharpshooter, is turned down by Frank Butler, who claims he only wants to marry a feminine woman – “a doll he can carry,” he explains in an even more recognizable song, “The Girl That I Marry.” When Frank Butler exits the stage, one might expect the forlorn Annie to launch into a ballad lamenting her unreturned feelings – and one would be pleasantly surprised with something completely different. Instead, she begins to belt the gutsy and lovable classic, “You Can’t Get a Man With a Gun,” complaining that being the best shot in the country doesn’t really mean squat when you’re trying to find a man. I’m not sure how far back this song and I go, since I first saw this show at age five, but I’ve always loved it. The role of Annie Oakley was created by Ethel Merman (only 20 years after the death of the actual Ms. Oakley), but my personal preference is for the revival recording, featuring Bernadette Peters, who presents the song with her crystal clear voice and adds her signature humor to her delivery of the lyrics.
Clip: You Can’t Get a Man With a Gun – Bernadette Peters
2. “Hello, Young Lovers” from The King and I (1951) – Rodgers and Hammerstein are the heroes of any modern musical fan. Or at least, I’d hope they are. I’ve gotten into arguments with my theater pals, on the topic of Rodgers and Hammerstein vs. Sondheim, but I won’t get into that. This is my editorial, and I say they’re heroes. So there (cue stomping of foot on ground like small child). I love most of their works, but have a definite soft spot for the tender love story in disguise, The King and I. “Hello, Young Lovers” is one of the most memorable songs from The King and I, but in fairness, most of the songs are pretty memorable. However, this has always been one of my favorites. It is the advice of a widowed woman, Anna, to a young couple going through that whole forbidden love plot that audiences find oh-so-sexy. Anna tells the couple to cherish each moment, and not to hold back, while at the same time reminiscing of her late husband and lover, Tom. And the melody is just downright catchy, which is why it was instantly my favorite song from the show when I heard it. The clip is of Julie Andrews as Anna singing this song for a film version of the show, and for the record, there is no one but Julie Andrews who plays Anna perfectly. No one.
Clip: Hello, Young Lovers – Julie Andrews
3. “In My Own Little Corner” from Cinderella (1957) – this song was technically not from a Broadway show (ah, technicalities). In the late 1950s, Richard Rodgers and Oscar Hammerstein II wrote an original score to accompany the classic fairytale, Cinderella. The music was used in a made-for-TV movie starring a young Julie Andrews as Cinderella, rather than a stage musical – it was the only work of Rodgers and Hammerstein’s that was made for anything other than the stage. The score is filled with instant classics (that, in my opinion, far surpass the syrupy songs in the Disney cartoon of the fairytale), such as “A Lovely Night” or the instrumental “Cinderella’s Waltz.” But the public favorite seems to be “In My Own Little Corner,” a song still performed frequently today. It’s just a quiet, slow song that takes place in Cinderella’s “happy place,” her little chair in the little corner by the fireplace. Mostly, she sings about freedom she experiences in this safe spot, where “she can be whatever she wants to be.” It displays a stunning amount of optimism if you ask me, since this woman’s life pretty much sucks, and yet she still sees the positive in this one place that she finds peace. I attached a clip from the 1997 movie version of Rodgers and Hammerstein’s Cinderella, produced by Disney (yes, Disney made a live action version of Cinderella – most people overlook it). That remake starred Brandy, with her gorgeously rich yet breathy soprano voice, as Cinderella.
Clip: In My Own Little Corner – Brandy
4. “Don’t Tell Mama” from Cabaret (1966) – for anyone unfamiliar with Kander and Ebb’s Cabaret, the whole show takes place in a cabaret-style German nightclub. One of the main characters is Sally, the headlining singer/dancer at the Kit-Kat Club. “Don’t Tell Mama” is Sally’s introduction song, or, by some definitions, her character song (the first song someone sings, usually giving background and insight into the character). In it, Sally pleads with all watching to keep her profession a secret from her mother (who apparently still believes Sally is touring Europe with her friends). It’s just a funny song, and since it’s from a classic show, I thought I’d include it. The original cast recording, featuring Jill Haworth as Sally Bowles, is below.
Clip: Don’t Tell Mama – Jill Haworth
5. “Music and the Mirror” from A Chorus Line (1975) – if there was ever a diva’s song, this is it. A Chorus Line is the pure definition of an ensemble show, and depending on how you look at it, there are either no main characters, or all seventeen cast members are main characters. And yet the pure diva energy radiating from one character in particular, Cassie, is so strong that attention always tends to be drawn to her. A Chorus Line tells the backstage story of every musical on Broadway, as it depicts seventeen young hopefuls auditioning to be in the chorus of a Broadway musical. Each sings of what got them to where they are, and of the emotional turmoil associated with being a working singer and dancer on Broadway. Cassie is a dancer desperate for work, and when she sings about her dedication to her craft in “Music and the Mirror,” it’s just unbelievable. Donna McKechnie, the original Cassie, was an utter unknown at the time, but as far as I’m concerned, no one has ever come close to matching her vocal performance in this role, and she doesn’t just play Cassie, she is Cassie. So naturally, the sample is of her on the original cast recording.
Clip: Music and the Mirror – Donna McKechnie
6. “Any Dream Will Do (Reprise)” from Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat (1982) – add to the list of composers I can’t possibly leave off this playlist, Andrew Lloyd Webber. Whether you love or hate Webber, his musicals are about as iconic as it gets. Phantom of the Opera and Cats alone defined nearly a decade of musical theater style. And while I haven’t had the chance to watch all the dozen or so musicals he’s composed, my favorite so far is one of his “oldies but goodies” – Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat. Or, as I prefer to call it, Joseph and the Ridiculously Long Show Title – or I just abbreviate it as Joseph. This show, based on the Bible story of Joseph and his dreams was technically my first opera – there is no dialogue in it; the two and a half hour show is all song. (By the end, my parents couldn’t believe me and my 6 to 8 year old siblings had sat through the whole thing.) Because of the nature of the show, most songs do not stand well alone, and therefore the only song that is usually performed outside of the original musical is Joseph’s solo “Any Dream Will Do.” The whole shtick with Joseph is that he can interpret dreams and predict the future from it. I actually laugh when I remember that it’s a Bible story, because to me it sounds more like the stories of some nutcase who believes himself to be psychic. Nevertheless, I do love this song, as he sings about his dreams along with a chorus of adorable children (who sit on the stage as a “audience” during the show, and whose purpose is not quite clear). I use the reprise version here because I think the music is more catchy, since it’s a finale song, and I just find it to be more pleasing to the ear than the first number, which is also very good. And for the record, the criteria I used for picking this clip out of the zillion cast recordings for this show is that this is the CD I have in my basement.
Clip: Any Dream Will Do (Reprise) – 1993 Broadway Revival Cast
7. “Castle on a Cloud” from Les Misérables (1985) – Les Misérables is a landmark show. Since first being performed in French in Paris in 1980, the show has been played in 38 different countries in dozens of major productions, and countless more smaller performances. Instantly recognizable are the soft, opening strains of piano in “I Dreamed a Dream,” or the charcoal sketch of a sad-looking girl in torn rags that is the Les Misérables logo. “Castle on a Cloud” is a song that can get overlooked in such an overwhelming show; with over 30 musical numbers, it’s hard to remember that soft ballad in the middle of act one that runs barely over a minute and a half. And yet I find it to be one of the most beautiful, emotional songs. The song is performed by a young actress, usually 8 or 9 years old, as the child version of the main character Cosette (the little girl in the logo). Cosette speaks of her fantasies, of a castle on a cloud she visits in her dreams, where she no longer has to work as an abused servant, and where she finds a mother figure to replace her real mother, who dies at the beginning of the show. It’s short but incredibly sweet and sung in a beautiful high octave. The clip below is of Donna Vivino (who, incidentally, has grown up into a beautiful vocalist that stunned half of Seattle with her performance in Wicked at the Paramount last September), from the original Broadway cast recording.
Clip: Castle on a Cloud – Donna Vivino
8. “I Know Him So Well” from Chess (1986) – obviously, I couldn’t include a song from Mamma Mia! on this list. (Face it, no matter how good the show is, “Dancing Queen” isn’t a showtune by any definition.) But fortunately, I managed to still use music composed by the very talented team of Andersson and Ulvaeus on my list, by picking a song from the West End flop musical, Chess. Chess as a show was an overall failure, because the story doesn’t stand up well, and by the second act, things start to fall apart. Well, wait, that’s a lie. I don’t know that for sure. I couldn’t bear to watch any more than the first ten minutes of act two, and after that, I was bashing my head against a wall – so hopefully you get what I mean about the show. However, the show is a favorite for concert-style engagements (when the show is performed usually just once or twice, with minimal staging and sets), because despite the weak plot, the music is very memorable and can almost compensate.”I Know Him So Well” is a great female duet, and has a lot of musical subtleties that remind a lot of ABBA’s music, so it’s a good example of how distinctive the composers can be. The song also has a great setup – two women are singing about the man they both love, one his wife, and one his mistress. It’s almost tragically funny how at the same point in this song, they both decide that giving up and letting the other woman have him is best for everyone. The clip is from a concert version of Chess that was performed in the West End in 2008 (it was only a two-show engagement, but the show was taped and broadcast on PBS), featuring Kerry Ellis and Idina Menzel, two very talented women whose voices I adore.
Clip: I Know Him So Well – Idina Menzel and Kerry Ellis
9. “Children Will Listen” from Into the Woods (1987) – truth be told, I don’t like Stephen Sondheim. And now I’ll pause and wait for you all to stop throwing tomatoes at me. We done? Okay, good. My opinions aside, I knew I simply could not compile a sampling of contemporary musical theater without including Sondheim. So here it is, my favorite song from the only Sondheim show I really like, Into the Woods. This song is the show’s finale song and was originally performed by Bernadette Peters. The song is now a classic and standard soprano ballad. As the lyrics state, “Careful the things you say, children will listen. Careful the things you do, children will see.” Bernadette Peters has a gorgeous, lilting soprano voice that I can’t possibly describe, and the lyrics are too deep for me to sit here and try to pick through. Listen to the sample. Seriously.
Clip: Children Will Listen – Bernadette Peters and Cast
10. “If I Can’t Love Her” from Beauty and the Beast (1994) – I tried to stray away from the adapted Disney movie musicals, since a lot of the songs from the movies are so mainstream by now, that I wouldn’t quite consider them “showtunes,” and Beauty and the Beast is a perfect case in point. But some of the songs that were written for the Broadway versions of the Disney stories are too amazing to overlook. And this act one closer is just so powerful, and heartbreaking, that I couldn’t leave it off. In a play that revolves around a romance, a dramatic break up or rejection song at the end of act one is pretty common, although I think the situation in Beauty and the Beast, and especially this song, is plenty unusual. I love this song because it’s one of the first times the Beast shows true emotion, and it is delivered in such a raw form. I’m sure that as high school students, most of you are far too mature for cartoons and have not watched Beauty and the Beast in years…right? *coughs* Uhm, yeah, so anyway – “If I Can’t Love Her” is sung right after Belle flees from the Beast’s castle. Despite his somewhat animalistic behavior, an audience gets the sense that Beast is trying desperately to fall in love with Belle – and more importantly, get her to see him in a different light, and love him in return, since this is the only way he’ll ever be a human again. And I do believe that when the maiden you’re trying to romance runs away from you, that’s a pretty strong sign that things aren’t going well. And all I have to say about the attached clip is, if you’ve never heard Terrence Mann sing, you have no idea how much you’re missing in life.
Clip: If I Can’t Love Her – Terrence Mann
11. “Seasons of Love” from Rent (1996) – Rent is one of the few shows whose scores I love so much that they’re on this list twice. And I tried to make myself cut this from the list, but I couldn’t. “Seasons of Love” is a practically universal song. Children sing it at events to make people feel warm and fuzzy, Girl Scouts sing it at summer camp around the fire, and it’s safe to say that most people of my generation have at least heard the song, even if they don’t know it’s from a Broadway show. All one needs to hear to recognize this gospel-style number are the simple but perfectly arranged piano chords that open the song, and the phrase, “525,600 minutes.” As I said before, it really is just a warm and fuzzy, feelgood song. The message is cliched, but important. Rent was, in a way, composer Jonathon Larson’s final message to the world, but I feel that this song in particular is Jonathon’s last gift to us.
Clip: Seasons of Love – Original Broadway cast
12. “Take Me or Leave Me” from Rent (1996) – this song is a beautiful example of the quirky style of rock music that makes up Rent. I felt I had to include an angry song if I put “Seasons of Love” on the list, because Rent is one of those works of art that is driven mainly by frustration, and much of the music carries that heavy, rock theme. I am a self-professed “Renthead” (yes, that is what us Rent geeks call ourselves), and would be hard-pressed to pick a favorite song from this music-packed operetta, but according to my iTunes top 25, my favorite is “Take Me or Leave Me.” There are many couples in Rent, most of them at least slightly dysfunctional, and the on-and-off relationship of characters Maureen and Joanne is perhaps the worst of all. During the course of the show, they break up about four times. (Possibly more. Truth be told, I’ve lost count.) This is probably because Maureen possesses several, shall we say, undesirable traits. (And yet she’s my favorite character…hmm.) During one of their arguments, Maureen presents an ultimatum to her angry girlfriend – take her as she is, or leave her. When Joanne tells Maureen the exact same thing, it turns into a powerful, frustrated song that is made of pure awesome. I chose to use the movie version of the song for the clip, because I think the music was better produced and sounds fuller than on the Broadway cast recording. It features Idina Menzel, the original Maureen, and Tracie Thoms as Joanne.
Clip: Take Me or Leave Me – Idina Menzel and Tracie Thoms
13. “My Strongest Suit” from Aida (2000) – I mentioned this song in my theater column once before, in my review of the rock opera Aida. And now I’m mentioning it again, because it is without a doubt, my favorite song from this show. The first time I heard it, I freaked out and immediately bought the entire cast album on iTunes. It’s long but absolutely worth listening to the whole thing. Full of high notes, riffs, and rock-style vocals, the song is amazing and incredibly hard to sing. “My Strongest Suit” has some of the most impressive belting I’ve ever heard, simply because it is in a high range that is nearly impossible to truly belt. (Trust me on this – I’ve tried. And it hurts to try to sing like Sherie does on the soundtrack.) It’s upbeat, catchy, and makes one want to dance and sing at the same time. It also stands alone well, since it’s more character than plot based. I’ve always thought it would make a great pop song. Take a listen to Sherie Rene Scott, Broadway semi-star, belt the heck out of this musical masterpiece. And listen to the lyrics, because they still make me laugh, as the character Amneris is supposed to be such an unabashedly spoiled princess that it’s kind of lovable. “Forget the inner me, observe the outer – I am what I wear, and how I dress.”
Clip: My Strongest Suit – Sherie Rene Scott
14. “Life of the Party” from Andrew Lippa’s The Wild Party (2000) – okay, technically, The Wild Party was never a Broadway show. At least not this version. Two musicals by this title, based on the same poem, were staged within a few months of each other in New York, completely coincidentally. Andrew Lippa’s off-Broadway version was the less successful of the two, though neither ran more than a few weeks. Personally, I prefer the Lippa version, but I’m a general fan of his scores, so I may be considered biased. To give an idea of the style of the music, since I’m sure most of my readers aren’t familiar with this show, it has been often compared to Kander and Ebb’s Chicago, since they both cary the same sort of vaudeville theme, and the shows are set in the same era. The show is full of great solos for each main character, and I agonized over choosing between this and the character Queenie’s saucy “Raise the Roof,” but I picked this, simply because I prefer the smoother succession of the music. I love the slight raspiness and overall roughness to these vocals and it’s definitely a musical highlight. “Life of the Party” is the only solo by this character, but it says all that needs to be said about her. The whole show is rather raunchy, and actually, this song could be considered mild compared to all the others. It’s simply a statement of the character’s way of life – lots of parties, lots of alcohol, and no work, all play.
Clip: Life of the Party – Idina Menzel
15. “Defying Gravity” from Wicked (2003) – most people, and certainly all theater fans, have heard of the musical Wicked, and “Defying Gravity” is the signature showstopper number from that record-breaking hit. It’s been modified into pop songs, sung on the musical TV sensation Glee, and is the most modern of the showtunes that are considered iconic and unforgettable. I know there are plenty of theater lovers who hate Wicked, but I can’t fathom hearing the final note in this song, watching the witch “fly” above the stage, and not getting goosebumps of thrill. The best belting ever, the most empowering music, and the craziest vocal performances are all packed into this song. To “defy gravity” may be a cliche – just search iTunes, and you’ll find a dozen songs with the same title – and all that’s usually meant by it is to rebel, defy all that is supposedly set in stone. But it becomes not-so-cliche when Elphaba actually does defy gravity. (This is an awesome special effect and a testament to the production values of Wicked.) I love this song. That’s all I can possibly say, because there is no other way to articulate my feelings for it. Every single time I listen to “Defying Gravity” – especially the powerhouse vocals, with the incredible belted high F, that take place in the last minute of the song – I love it more and more. And while anyone who can successfully pull this off is a brilliant singer, there was no option but to use a clip of the sensational original Elphaba, Idina Menzel. And before you hit play, turn your speakers down, because this woman’s voice is intense enough to blow them up if you’re not careful.
Clip: Defying Gravity – Idina Menzel and Kristin Chenoweth
16. “What is This Feeling?” from Wicked (2003) – this song must go on the list not because it illustrates a standard style used in theater songs, but rather, because it is the complete opposite of many of those standards. The title implies a song about a new found crush, and “love at first sight” songs, though usually unrealistic, are quite popular in musical theater. However, love at first sight is not quite the case with the main characters in Wicked. In actuality, the song is a hate at first sight song. Comically enough, I have actually heard this referred to as “the best lesbian love song in the history of theater,” because it really sounds like that’s what it will turn out to be if you just listen to the first verse of lyrics. “What is this feeling, so sudden and new? I felt the moment, I laid eyes on you….” Could it be lust? No, it is in fact, “loathing! unadulterated loathing!” I love this song just because of the pure comedy of these two girls who barely know each other pronouncing their hatred for each other, and the fact that they’re singing it. It twists what is the standard, which is what any fantastic song from a musical must do. And if I ever find myself thrown into a situation where I know the minute I meet someone that I hate them, I would rather sing to them than yell at them. Seems like a much nicer thing to do, don’t you think? So, here’s the clip, once again of the original witches of Wicked, Idina Menzel and Kristin Chenoweth.
Clip: What is This Feeling? – Idina Menzel and Kristin Chenoweth
17. “For Good” from Wicked (2003) – yes, another song from Wicked. I can’t help it – the show is so packed with different emotions and styles and heartstopping vocal performances that I feel I can’t represent it all with one or even two songs. “For Good” is possibly the most beautiful song I’ve ever heard, and I can’t even tell you how hard I cried the first time I saw this show. It’s what would be called the “eleven o’clock” number in the standard musical formula – the last song in the show, before the “finale” number, almost always soaring and powerful. (The name comes from the fact that the second to last song in a show was usually performed around 11 pm – there’s your random bit of theater trivia for the day.) Wicked is, in essence, a love story – but a different kind of love story. Totally platonic, which is why the kiddies love it. The whole show is about the relationship between Glinda and Elphaba (the Good and Wicked witches of Oz, respectively), and “For Good” is the sad conclusion and overall summary of the relationship. At this point in the show, Elphaba and Glinda know they will never see each other again, and they have this one moment – one song, as it works in musicals – to express everything that the other has meant to them, and say their final goodbyes. (Oh, there I go. I’m tearing up just writing this.) The song is led into by one last joke before the tears start, as the social outcast Elphaba tells Glinda, “You’re the only friend I’ve ever had.” To which little miss popular replies, “And I’ve had so many friends!” The tender moment is saved, as she continues, “But only one…that mattered.” And then they sing, and the whole audience reaches for the Kleenex.
Clip: For Good – Idina Menzel and Kristin Chenoweth
18. “My Junk” from Spring Awakening (2006) – Spring Awakening is a show that is amazing beyond belief, and I suggest that you listen to the entire soundtrack, because it’s that good. (However, it is R-rated, so maybe wait until the kid you’re babysitting goes to bed.) But I chose this song, “My Junk,” for my list, because it’s a great ensemble piece. Although the show takes place in the late 19th century, the high school students at the center of it are portrayed as being more modern, as reflected in this song. All of the young girls are explaining their feelings for the boys they each like, referring to their hangups on said boys similarly to addiction, hence the title. I also love this song just because I like the cast, since Spring Awakening was cast with very talented but mostly smaller names, young adults who hadn’t made a name for themselves in the theater yet. (The recording below also includes Lea Michele, the original female lead of Spring Awakening, and beloved star of that one TV show that nobody can stop talking about.)
Clip: My Junk – Original Broadway Cast
19. “Listen to Your Heart” from Young Frankenstein (2007) – the original draft of this list included a song from The Producers, but I had to cut it because the list was getting WAY too long. But I did include another great Mel Brooks musical, the Broadway adaptation of the movie Young Frankenstein. “Listen to Your Heart” is meant to be a flirty love song, but as is usually the case in a Mel Brooks show, the lyrics are so far from what you’d expect, it makes for great comedy. As Dr. Frankenstein’s flirty lab assistant tries to persuade him to go on his emotions rather than rationality, she also tries to explain to him that for the best romance, it’s a good idea to give up on any thinking. To quote the lyrics, her exact suggestion to him is, “Let’s be stupid together!” It’s very romantic, really. In the clip, Sutton Foster is playing Inga the lab assistant. And Sutton Foster is, as a friend of mine might say, utterly fabulous.
Clip: Listen To Your Heart – Sutton Foster
20. “I Want the Good Times Back” from The Little Mermaid (2008) – consensus among all my theater geek friends is that this is probably the funniest villain song ever. Written by original Little Mermaid composer Alan Menken and newer Disney-employed lyricist Glenn Slater, it is probably the best of the songs added to the Broadway version. Ursula the Sea Witch didn’t have enough of a part in the movie in my opinion, considering that she’s the main antagonist in the plot. I also wasn’t a fan of the way the original voice actress portrayed the character, and find the revamp from cranky old hag to sarcastic comic villainness to be quite refreshing. Sherie Rene Scott managed to make Ursula all her own, and practically created a new role. Part of the new character is a quality of shamelessness – almost pride – at her utterly evil intentions. “I Want the Good Times Back” is also a perfect example of an “I want” song, a song that states a main character’s goal at the beginning of the show (usually the second or third song), and in this one, Ursula and her two eel henchmen long for the days when they wreaked havoc on all inhabitants of the ocean, and the lyrics are just hilarious. She sings of wanting back the feelings of causing destruction, crushing spirits, and being on top of the world – er, sea. And sure, “it’s sheer abuse of power,” but “ain’t that what power’s for?!”
Clip: I Want the Good Times Back – Sherie Rene Scott
I apologize to any theater geek whose favorites were left out. I’m a bit biased. That’s why this is in the opinion/editorial section. Comment with your favorite showtunes below if you’d like, because I’d love to hear from you!
VN:F [1.9.1_1087]
Rating: 5.0/5 (2 votes cast)